Convertible bonds have long been lauded for their unique investment profile, often characterized by the phrase “downside protection with upside potential.” Historically, this has fostered a popular investment strategy known as "bad company, good convertible bonds," where investors sought out debt securities issued by struggling firms, banking on potential recovery or better terms in the futureHowever, recent market upheavals have arguably shattered this paradigm, necessitating a return to fundamental financial analysis and a deeper understanding of the market dynamics that govern these instruments.

Following the expansion of the convertible bond market in September 2017, a period of unprecedented growth unfolded, ushering in a five-year boom that lasted until 2023. The market grew from a mere hundred billion yuan valuation to nearly a trillion, with trading volumes skyrocketing from a few billion yuan per day to over a hundred billion

Notably, from the beginning of 2018, convertible bond indices consistently outperformed broader market indices in terms of annualized returns, volatility, and risk-reward ratios, cementing their reputation as a hybrid financial product with attractive beta characteristics.

Yet, with the recent volatility in convertible bond prices, one must wonder whether the traditional investment logic that has sustained this sector for years remains intactThe market's fluctuations pose crucial questions: Where are the new opportunities for investors amidst dramatic downturns? These are essential points that require careful consideration and strategic reflection.

To unpack the current landscape, we can examine three major downturns in the convertible bond market, which have shaped investor sentiment and strategies over the years

• Learning from the Historical Lessons of Protectionism
• Are Robots on the Horizon?
• Flying Car Development Soars with Automaker Backin
• Stable Trends in the Global Commodity Market
• Micron Shares Plunge 16% on Weak Forecast

The first significant decline, marked in 2018, resulted from a broader equity market downturn that saw nearly all main indices dip sharplyThe Shanghai Composite Index fell by nearly 20%, while small-cap indices experienced declines exceeding 30%. Throughout this turmoil, the convertible bond pricing mechanism acted like a compressed spring, reaching an unsustainable low.

The lowest point in the market was recorded on October 18, 2018, when trading activity plummeted to a meager 690 million yuan across 92 convertible bondsThis date remains a reference point for many traders, as the average closing price settled at about 94.74 yuan, with a median price of just 93.13 yuanThe average yield at that time was a paltry 3.58%, illustrating the limitations of the market at this nadirThe fear of defaults hadn't yet taken root, signaling a curious juxtaposition of risk versus reward.

What followed was a recovery spurred by rising equity indices and a renewed appetite from institutional investors, coinciding with the advent of more robust fixed-income products and strategies

Despite the revival, the ghost of past collapses lingered, especially during the early days of 2021 when the market faced another wave of panic, primarily linked to credit events among major corporations.

The notorious defaults involving AAA-rated entities at the end of 2020 sent shockwaves through the market, leading to rapid price declines in convertible securities as investor sentiment turned bearishThose lessons were pivotal; they reinforced the notion that even in seemingly safe investment vehicles, distortion and volatility could rear their heads.

In contrast, the market experienced another significant adjustment in April 2022, primarily tied to plummeting equity pricesThis decline was noteworthy for its resilience, as the market ground downwards, failing to reach the depths observed in previous downturns thanks to increased market capacity and institutional participation

The difference is stark against the dramatic pressures of 2018; the market has matured, with a varied spectrum of risk management strategies employed by investors.

As we take stock of these developments, we can identify the factors contributing to these downturnsPrimarily, investor confidence in the equity markets plays a crucial role, alongside the unavoidable specter of credit risks that can act as secondary catalysts, affecting convertible bond pricing and the related confidence of stakeholders.

What is markedly different in the recent upheaval is the emergence of identifiable risk factors that had previously gone unrecognized by the investing publicEvents this past year, particularly the withdrawal of listings for underperforming convertible bonds and the subsequent default by Sohu Te, have crystallized the idea that the market can no longer rely solely on the assumption of downside protection.

These incidents have highlighted essential risks related to delisting, both from operational failures and poor financial performance

Investors must now vigilantly monitor firms for signs of prolonged losses, insufficient revenue bases, and red flags in audit opinions, as such elements could signal imminent risks of a convertible bond's default.

In addition, as institutions begin to tighten their evaluation criteria, the landscape of convertible bond issuances is evolvingThe need to closely watch credit ratings and the corresponding implications of downgrades has never been more critical, as disappearing market support can lead to rapid price declines.

Moreover, market risks associated with the general health of underlying assets and their impact on convertible bonds cannot be understatedA significant presence of convertible bonds relative to a company’s market capitalization can strain equity valuations, potentially triggering wider market repercussions

Additionally, factors such as higher debt-to-equity ratios and lower current and projected income streams create fertile ground for significant downward price pressures.

Given these findings, it is clear that the strategy of "bad company, good convertible bonds" must be re-evaluatedInvestors will need to return to the basic principles of analyzing fundamentals, understanding industry trends, and assessing macroeconomic factors as essential pillars of their investing frameworkThe notion that convertible bonds can serve as a safe harbor is now complicated by the realities of credit risk and market fluctuations.

The surviving thread of volatility remains a cornerstone for profitability in these financial instrumentsEach cyclical downturn carries inherent opportunities if investors can pinpoint and leverage disparities in the market metrics seen during different phases

Amidst current market noise, one must also look at statistical benchmarks; the medians and averages can reveal transformative insights about emerging market opportunities.

The current wealth of convertible bond data enables thoughtful analysis of price medians, especially when considering historical highs and lowsAn investigation of the present dynamics shows that recent averages are unlikely to dip to extreme lows seen during previous years largely due to increased institutional and retail participationThe average returns — as measured by yield — have notably increased, albeit slightly hampered by less liquid attractive securities.

Investors seeking value must exercise caution, eliminating potential pitfalls while scanning for opportunitiesThe balance between financial health indicators, market pressure, and yield prospects allows astute investors to navigate potential mispricings effectively