Global Central Banks Risk Returning to Divergence

Advertisements

In the global arena of economic policymaking, central banks are actively preparing for what's being referred to as a "2.0" eraNotably, economies like Canada and the Eurozone appear increasingly concerned about potential economic downturns, prompting more aggressive interest rate cutsIn contrast, the Federal Reserve (the Fed) of the United States is primarily focused on the risk of resurfacing inflation, implying a cautious approach toward its current rate reduction strategyThis divergence in monetary policy illustrates a potentially fragmented global economic landscape, consequently requiring investors to adapt to this novel investment environment.

According to Kualfi, the Global Head of Multi-Asset Investment Management at Fidelity International, the Federal Reserve is currently evaluating various policy trajectories, leading to adjustments in economic forecasts for 2025. Europe, he points out, is grappling with structural challenges

Since 2023, the Eurozone economy has nearly stagnated, facing an array of cyclical and structural hurdlesHowever, he indicates that easing inflation and lowering interest rates could pave the way for a revival in corporate capital expenditure and consumer confidence, suggesting that the European economy may experience a cyclical upswing by 2025. An increase in real disposable income, facilitated by more lenient financing conditions, could potentially unleash excess savings and spur consumption growthNonetheless, trade uncertainties stemming from U.Stariffs carry the risk of dampening the region’s economic growth by as much as 0.5 percentage points.

Focusing specifically on the U.S., Kualfi believes Fidelity's basic forecast indicates a shift from a soft landing of the economy towards rising inflation, suggesting a transition away from reliance on unprecedented growth to a protective domestic focus

This set of circumstances may involve expansionary fiscal policies and significant tariff hikesFactors such as strong consumer spending, robust private sector balance sheets, and a resilient yet somewhat weak labor market mitigate the overall risk of recessionIn this context, possible reform measures from a new U.Sgovernment could enhance inflationary pressures, making it likely that inflation will rise comprehensively starting in the second quarter of 2025. Should the new U.Sgovernment pursue protectionist goals, the actual impact on economic performance, despite negotiation-induced reductions in tariff rates, could still be significantCombined stimuli plans and accommodative fiscal policies may elevate inflation and diminish the risk of recession in the U.SOther major economies, particularly in Europe and China, will need to navigate the shifting trade and industry policies from the U.S., which could, in turn, influence the American growth outlook

Moreover, the rising burden of government debt poses a long-term challenge; public finances in the U.Smay soon reach their limits.

The Fed's cycle of interest rate cuts is set to become more volatileAfter adopting a hawkish stance on rate cuts, multiple analysts anticipate that the current cycle of reductions will experience increased turbulenceWilting, a managing director and economist at Pinhao, posits that the Fed may elect for a hold on interest rates in its upcoming January meetingFed Chair Powell maintained that while the restrictive nature of the policy has clearly lessened, it remains constrainedThe likelihood of restoring rate hikes is deemed low before the Fed observes further control over inflation or an uptick in unemployment rates.

From the perspective of Sonora, the head of U.Seconomic research at Fitch Ratings, while the U.Seconomy continues to demonstrate solid growth and favorable labor market conditions, an inflationary storm is brewing

alefox

He notes that the recent meeting reflects the Fed's acknowledgment of anticipated inflation policies from the 2025 U.SgovernmentCurrently, rather than consider skipping rate cuts, the Fed seems inclined towards a pauseHowever, it is evident that the Fed’s grasp on its policy directional trajectory is less certain than it was three months ago, necessitating preparation for fluctuations in monetary policies leading into 2025.

Martilos, a macro strategist with Wellington Investment Management, emphasizes that while the Fed has not explicitly commented on potential supply-side policy changes for the coming year, such as tariffs and immigration restrictions, its actions suggest a preference for addressing the possibility of rising inflation over declining growth risksThis development is pivotal as it indicates the Fed's unwillingness to compromise its autonomy under increasing political pressure in favor of rate cuts

Nonetheless, Powell has consistently signaled that all options remain on the table and adjustments will be made based on actual conditionsReflecting on past months, once inflation stabilizes at levels above expectations, the Fed is likely to recalibrate its policy orientationConsequently, future volatility in inflation could spur increased fluctuations in policy and interest rates.

Crucially, the Summary of Economic Projections (SEP) signals a more hawkish trajectory for policy rates in the years aheadThis dynamic underscores the growing concern within the Fed regarding the stickiness of inflation observed over the past three monthsIn a recent press conference, Powell revealed that the decision to cut rates by 25 basis points or pause was exceedingly closeThe implications of the SEP indicate that the threshold for tempering rate cuts in the following year has significantly lowered.

The significance of the Fed's shift in policy can be attributed to several factors

Primarily, it indicates that policymakers would adjust their forecasts based on actual economic growth and inflation outcomesAlongside this, a sustained focus on inflationary risks will likely overshadow signs of slowing growth and labor market weaknessesRising skepticism regarding the Fed's independence is an increasing concern, yet Powell continues to signal that the Fed will maintain its emphasis on its dual mandate, particularly with heightened regards to inflation pressuresThis focus is critical for analyzing potential policy shifts in 2025.

According to Persley, the Chief U.SEconomist at Prudential, greater attention is being drawn to the Fed's year-end fiscal decisions compared to its early-year strategiesAs 2023 comes to a close, the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) has issued unexpected signals regarding anticipated rises in both inflation and economic growth rates in 2025, indicating a slowing in the pace of rate cuts for the following year

Measures suggested in the SEP imply that the Fed may be shifting its focus to a dual mission of managing inflation and employmentAt the same time, the Fed has raised the terminal rate to 3.1%, a figure 75 basis points higher than its 2021 low, suggesting that its current policy stance lacks the expected restrictive qualities seen beforeNotably, an FOMC member voted to keep rates steady due to the stickiness of inflation and the gradually rising unemployment rate, suggesting Powell’s emphasis on “data dependency” will increasingly become a focal point for consensus within the FOMCExpectations indicate that the Fed will probably pause rate cuts in its January meeting, awaiting additional data before determining whether to resume or cease the rate reduction cycle.

Zhao, a global market strategist for Invesco Asia Pacific (excluding Japan), holds a more optimistic outlook

He remarks that the market's reaction to unexpected projections from the dot plot may stem from instinctual responses, but observes that such projections can often be inaccurateFor example, in December 2021, the Fed's dot plot forecasted that rate hikes for 2022 would not exceed 100 basis points, yet the actual figure surpassed 400 basis pointsAlthough the recent rate cut reflects a hawkish disposition, it is worth noting that the extent of that cut exceeds the easing phase seen between 1995 and 1996, when the U.Smanaged to evade a recession and subsequently experienced robust growthUltimately, he argues that the Fed's policy will remain data-driven, prompting a heightened focus on future economic indicators.

For investors, the divergence in central bank policies and narrowing regional credit spreads present opportunities for global fixed-income strategiesThe investment landscape now calls for a flexible approach that encompasses corporate bonds and government debt valued in various currencies, as well as investment-grade, high-yield, and emerging market bonds.

Driscoll of Fidelity International observes that with certain market spreads remaining elevated, investors should adopt a global perspective to seek optimal value

He expresses a relative optimism towards European credit markets, as they offer more attractive credit valuations compared to the U.S., particularly within the financial sectorThe high interest rates typically benefit banks, which are expected to maintain robust fundamentals and solid credit health, thereby supporting investments in this sectorEuropean banks, less reliant on trade and the global economic outlook compared to export-oriented enterprises, are further bolstered by local policies that could help mitigate the prevailing trends in protectionism.

From a rate perspective, he notes that the uncertainty surrounding U.STreasury premiums may persist, necessitating diverse bond duration portfolios going into 2025. Meanwhile, as fixed-income investment yields remain at historical highs, there remain attractive total return prospects in higher-quality corporate bondsIn the high-yield bond sector, he advises focusing on firms with stronger certainties rather than pursuing elevated returns within riskier frameworks

Overall, he stresses the importance of risk management, guiding investor focus towards companies with favorable fundamental trends, while steering clear of those burdened by high leverage.

Persley contends the hawkish position taken by Powell will yield immediate implications for the U.Sfixed income marketMarket expectations for rate cuts in 2025 have rapidly adjusted, dropping from a forecast of 50 basis points to 30 basis pointsThis transition has led to a decline in short-term bond yields by 10 to 15 basis points, while long-term yields decreased by about 8 basis pointsThis flattening trend in the Treasury yield curve is likely to endure, leading to increased volatility in risk assets and wider spreads in high-yield bondsGiven the Fed's tempered approach to reducing rates, it is anticipated that the market's focus will intensify on economic events in the coming year.

Martilos suggests that as more evidence emerges indicating a convergence between structural and cyclical factors propelling U.S

Treasury yields higher, this trend is expected to persist over the next 3 to 6 monthsDuring this period, volatility is also likely to escalate, particularly considering the timing and impact of supply-side shocks related to trade and immigration, alongside fiscal policy ramifications.

In light of current trends, we maintain our expectation of continued, albeit more gradual, loosening of policies, with the global economy anticipated to accelerate in the coming yearBased on these projections, we anticipate that risk assets will perform favorably in 2024. However, a rebound in inflation represents a critical uncertainty in investments, which appears increasingly plausible, especially if the FOMC’s actions reflect the influence of U.Sgovernmental policies before data acquisition, necessitating preemptive measures to contain inflationAdditional scrutiny of the dollar's strength and its potential adverse impacts on emerging market assets remains crucial.

post your comment